Antiques Roadshow: 40 Years of Great Finds. Paul AtterburyЧитать онлайн книгу.
they had been heavily restored.’ For this reason, he valued the pair at £50,000, a price that would be difficult to sustain today because of fluctuations in the Irish market.
‘What started out as a copy became a major Orpen discovery, and revealed a First World War mystery – the Roadshow at its best.’
Rupert Maas
In 2009 the Roadshow returned to Greenwich, a classic Thames-side setting framed by glorious architecture. The sun shone and people turned out in their thousands. It was a typically diverse day, with several items inevitably linked to the river and its history.
A gentleman brought in a striking portrait of a beautiful girl, which he believed to be a copy of a painting by William Orpen. At first sight, expert Rupert Maas agreed with him, but then began to have doubts. Before too long, Rupert realised that he wasn’t looking at a copy, but probably at an original painting by Orpen. The situation was further confused by Orpen having signed the painting in a coded way.
THE WAR ARTIST
Sir William Orpen was the most successful British artist of the early twentieth century and the most famous portrait painter of his age. Extravagant, outgoing and a lover of the high life in all its forms, Orpen was also a great painter with a distinctive style that combined modernism with a healthy respect for Vermeer, Velásquez and other European masters. During the First World War, he was appointed an official war artist, given the honorary rank of major and sent to France in the spring of 1917. He began with portraits – of Sir Douglas Haig and others – and then widened his brief to include battlefield scenes creating, in the process, some of the greatest works produced by the war artists’ scheme.
The owner knew little about the painting but liked it very much and, encouraged by Rupert, he warmed to the idea that it might actually be by Orpen. However, with the limited research facilities available to him at the Roadshow, Rupert was not able to confirm the Orpen attribution, so he valued it for £20,000 to £30,000, pending further research. In due course, Rupert established that the portrait was indeed by Orpen and also that it was a second, hitherto unknown, version of a famous painting in the Imperial War Museum. At that point he revalued it for £250,000.
In the winter of 1917, William Orpen met and fell in love with a young Belgian girl named Yvonne Aubicq, who was to occupy a major place in his life, and his heart, until 1928. He immediately painted her in the direct and provocative manner for which he was famous, planning to show this portrait of Yvonne in an exhibition to be held at Agnew’s in London, early in 1918. He then remembered that, as an employed official war artist, he was only allowed to paint war pictures or those with war themes. In addition, the contract issued to official war artists stated that all paintings completed while ‘on duty’ were to be offered to the government, which had first refusal, and had to be submitted for censorship. As a result, no private work could be undertaken. To overcome this difficulty, he titled the painting The Refugee. He then went even further down a dangerous route by renaming it The Spy, and inventing and widely distributing a story about a glamorous German spy named Frida Nater, captured and shot by the French, whom he had been able to paint shortly before her execution.
After the filming the second version of Yvonne's portrait was briefly reunited with the Imperial War Museum's famous original, on the left.
A GLAMOROUS STORY
According to Orpen’s story, Frida was granted a last wish – to wear clothes of her choice for her execution. She chose a magnificent fur coat and, when the order was given, she dropped the coat and faced the firing squad completely naked, perhaps in the hope that the soldiers would not be able to carry out their orders. Nevertheless, she was shot. Inevitably, the truth came out, and Orpen ended up in trouble with the War Office. However, he recovered from this setback and continued to work as a war artist, not only throughout the duration of the war but also at the Paris Peace Conference in 1919. Now called The Refugee once more, this portrait of Yvonne is among over 130 works by Sir William Orpen in the collections of the Imperial War Museum.
Once all this had been established, the owner decided to sell the painting. At first, it was going to be sold at auction, and then it was sold privately, and is now in a private collection in Australia. The price paid was in the area of Rupert’s revised valuation.
Sometimes objects are brought to the Roadshow and, although they do not have any significant financial value, they offer an unusual and often personal insight into great moments in history. Inevitably, many of these tell stories about global conflict in the twentieth century. A typical example occurred at Lincoln Cathedral in 2009, when a man brought in the stub of a cigar purportedly smoked by Winston Churchill.
Throughout the Second World War, a series of international conferences was held by the leaders of the Allied countries to determine strategy, to plan future action within the various theatres of conflict and to plan the postwar peace. There were over twenty people involved, some of whom are household names, intricately and enduringly associated with the shaping of the modern world, while others languish in obscurity, remembered only by specialist historians. One of the most important conferences was held in Casablanca, North Africa, in January 1943. Churchill (the British prime minister), President Roosevelt of the United States and General De Gaulle of France were present, along with teams of military and civilian advisors. Among the decisions made were the declaration of the doctrine of unconditional surrender, the invasion of Sicily to take place later in 1943, the commitment to an invasion of mainland Europe in 1944, the ongoing support of Russia, greater support from Britain for the Pacific war and the creation of a Free French force under de Gaulle.
The owner of the cigar stub revealed to Fiona Bruce that, while serving in the British Army, his grandfather was employed as a butler during the ten days of the Casablanca conference. At some point, he had collected one of Churchill’s cigar stubs, along with place markers bearing the names of important people attending the conference, including Harold Macmillan (later a British prime minister), Lord Alexander and King Peter of Yugoslavia.
Churchill, famously, was a great cigar smoker and around the world there are many cigar stubs and, indeed, whole cigars associated with him. Fiona pointed out that the provenance was all-important, as it is with all objects connected to famous people. The owner replied that he only knew what his grandfather had told him, and saw no reason to doubt his word. Given that the Churchill connection seemed definite, and the historical location important, the cigar stub was valued at £600–£800.
‘I got such a shock. I just couldn’t believe it. I just rocked backwards and forwards. It’s better than the stock market.’
This was the reaction of a Melbourne lady who had just heard that her teddy bear was worth $200,000. In 2005, the Roadshow visited Australia, with two locations, Sydney and Melbourne. The first programme was filmed at Sydney University, the second in Melbourne’s great exhibition building, a remarkable legacy of the International Exhibition of 1880, and the oldest